Subject: Deterioration within enclosures
The discussion of damage caused by the encapsulation of acidic materials reminds me of a puzzle that I think about from time to time. It relates to the damage caused by the old wooden slat backings used in picture frames. Why is this damage so extreme where there are gaps in the backing, that is, where two slats join or where there is a knot hole? I suppose that it could be from greater exposure to atmospheric pollution, but then wouldn't the atmosphere within the frame be more polluted (acid gases, peroxides, etc., from the bare wood) than that without? Could it be that the oxygen becomes somewhat depleted further from the opening? (This would have implications regarding encapsulation of acidic materials.) Could the paper be more mechanically damaged there from expansion and contraction because it is less buffered from changes in exterior temperature and relative humidity? Might this mechanical stress result in shortening of the cellulose chain? Perhaps it is because there is a greater amount of exposed wood surface there since narrow edges of the slats are also in the vicinity. I personally am skeptical that the latter factor alone could result in such an increase in the amount of damage. Perhaps it is because the noxious gases within are forced through the paper near this opening when there are changes in atmospheric pressure. On the other hand, one would think that there would be less buildup of these damaging gases within the enclosure at this point because they can more easily escape. I would appreciate anyone's thoughts on the matter. Dan Clement Paper Conservator Ithaca, NY *** Conservation DistList Instance 6:51 Distributed: Tuesday, March 23, 1993 Message Id: cdl-6-51-009 ***Received on Tuesday, 23 March, 1993