Re: [ARSCLIST] E or F?

[-=sVo=- <svorg@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

From mostly the same sources, it's in E.

Scott


On Mon, 29 Oct 2007 11:21:04 -0400, David Lennick <dlennick@xxxxxxxxxxxx>  
wrote:
> There is now about to be a gigantic Homer Simpson "D'oh!" moment as I  
> beat myself over the head with the album cover and admit that I can't  
> read (or something). Please do not ask why I wrote "Crown Imperial".
>
> It's "ORB AND SCEPTRE".
>
> Many apologies. Now..E or F?
>
> (Elgar's Imperial March is also on this album, I know Crown Imperial  
> from other contexts, blah blah blah. Sorry!)
>
> dl
>
> -=sVo=- wrote:
> > I just checked three British orchestral recordings, a Wind Band  
> > recording, and a transcribed organ arrangement, plus I have played the  
> > organ part several times with both orchestras and bands and can vouch  
> > that all of the above and every arrangement I have ever seen are in C.
> >  Scott VanOrnum
> > Musician
> > Ann Arbor, MI
> >    On Sun, 28 Oct 2007 22:35:27 -0400, David Lennick  
> > <dlennick@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> > > Quick, geniuses..is Walton's "Crown Imperial" March in E or F? Got it  
> > > here on a London LP that at 33.3 plays exactly between those keys.  
> > > Other tracks on the LP aren't as far off pitch..which way do we go? My  
> > > instincts tell me E.
> > >
> > > Thanks
> > > dl


--
-=sVo=-