Lou,
True, as a blanket statement it is a bit useless. But in a live situation, I would almost always deal with a singer that is too loud than one that is too soft, and I have encountered the latter far more frequently. Few singers can overload an SM-58, although it does happen. But if you have a drum kit and rock guitars behind a whispering singer... that's when the trouble starts. I see that much more with younger perfromers, the ones that have grown up overdubbing their vocals, or in a separate vocal booth.
There was one young band that played what they called "old-timey" music and tried the "old-timey" approach of having just one microphone on a [small] stage, which I was looking forward to. It was a disaster: their singing could not be heard above their instruments, and they said they could not hear themselves. Microphone or not, their balance was *acoustically* way off.
Marcos
----- Original Message ----- From: "Lou Judson" <loujudson@xxxxxxx>
To: <ARSCLIST@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
Sent: Tuesday, August 29, 2006 10:15 AM
Subject: Re: [ARSCLIST] Not using headphones
I do live sound for a lot of acoustic music, and find wide variation in singing delivery. I don't think a generalization like "singers do not project" is viable as a blanket statement - I know many too loud as well as too soft, and an unfortunate few with no fear at all!
But then I don't see much electric music or rock kind of thing at all either... You may be right though.
<L>
Lou Judson • Intuitive Audio 415-883-2689
On Aug 29, 2006, at 5:26 AM, Marcos Sueiro Bal wrote:
I have started to think that is a big psychological factor as well,
and a
big reason for why singers do not project when singing live anymore.